THE GOOD:
1. A tribute to one of my favorite genres and an important cultural reference, the spaghetti western.
2. A friendly (if small) gaming community. WQ3 is a labor of love, first by the Iron Claw folks and now by Red Neckerson and the gang. Thanks to all for keeping Western Quake alive!
3. Realistic weapon damage and no health packs. The damage factor is important to me because I?ve gotten disgusted with other games and mods where it is possible to empty an entire clip from an assault rifle (say) into a player and not take him out. WQ3: one good headshot and yer gone. Not having health packs livens up the strategy-- do I buy a shotgun when my health is 44?
4. Some of the animations are great. I love the fall a dead player takes off the roof. Just like the movies.
THE BAD:
1. Bots can see you and kill you through doors. (Even two doors, in the case of the Train map.) Of course, the fact that they always run (and thus make noise) evens things up.
2. I think weapon switching is too slow in the case of pistols. The whirling is fun, but frustrating when I?m in a fight.
THE UGLY:
These are just quibbles I made up to have an ?ugly? section.

1. Realism is spoiled when the bots get stuck trying to get through windows.
2. Again, those bots. They don?t look very macho when they start bobbing up and down trying to figure out whether to crouch or not.